Pinchy's Lobster + Rawbar

Looking for legit Maine lobster in the Smokies? Pinchy's Lobster + Rawbar in downtown Sevierville delivers the real deal, with Connecticut-style lobster rolls that rival anything you'll find in New England. Each roll comes packed with generous portions of fresh lobster meat, justifying the $30 price point for seafood lovers who know their stuff.

The Monday all-you-can-eat crab legs special has become a local institution, with steaming platters arriving one pound at a time until you cry uncle. While the seafood quality is top-notch, the setting keeps it casual - think cafeteria-style seating with energetic acoustics. The outdoor beer garden, complete with fire pits and dog-friendly policies, offers a more laid-back atmosphere for enjoying their impressive craft beer selection.

Don't skip the appetizers - the crab wontons and lobster mac and cheese have earned their spot as menu favorites. The kitchen also surprises with an unexpectedly solid sushi program and creative specials that blend coastal flavors with Appalachian influences.

Budget-wise, expect to invest in your meal - dinner for two typically runs $80-100 before tip, reflecting the premium cost of getting fresh seafood to Tennessee. The portions are generous though, and the quality justifies the price point for special occasions or serious seafood cravings.

The service team, including standouts like Kally, Mary, and Misty, consistently elevates the experience with their knowledge and attention to detail. They're happy to guide first-timers through the menu and make recommendations based on your preferences. For the best experience, avoid peak tourist hours and consider making reservations during high season.