Johnny Carino's - Restaurant in Pigeon Forge, Tennessee
Restaurant$$

Johnny Carino's

Pigeon Forge2425 Parkway Pigeon Forge TN 37863
8.8
Excellent

Duration

1-2 hours for a meal

Price

$12.99 - $20.99 for main dishes

Best For

Families looking for large portions • Groups wanting affordable dining • Visitors seeking a quiet atmosphere

Pro Tip

Order the 'Create Your Own Pasta' base with toppings to maximize value from large portions.

About Johnny Carino's

We've eaten at Johnny Carino's probably a dozen times over the years, and honestly, it's become our go-to when we need to feed a big group without breaking the bank. The portions are absolutely massive — like, plan on taking half your meal home massive. Their wood-fired pizzas are solid, especially Johnny's Favorite loaded with everything, but don't sleep on the pasta dishes either.

The bread service hits different here. They bring out warm herb bread with olive oil right when you sit down, and it's unlimited, but seriously pace yourself because the entrées are no joke size-wise.

Location-wise, it's right on the Parkway at 2425, so parking can be a nightmare during peak times. We've learned to either get there by 5:30 for dinner or just call ahead for takeout when the strip is packed. The dining room stays pretty quiet even with TVs going, which is nice when you're trying to actually have a conversation.

One thing though — if you're thinking this is just another chain restaurant, you're not wrong, but the portions make it worth it for families. The Create Your Own Pasta for $12.99 plus toppings is probably the best value on the menu, and you can easily split it between two people. Just know that Friday and Saturday nights after 6 PM turn into a tourist zoo, so plan accordingly.

Last updated: April 4, 2026 • Based on 3,745 reviews

Amenities & Features

Massive portions that reliably provide leftovers for another mealItalian nachos (especially with chicken) and stuffed vegetarian mushrooms are standout menu itemsExceptionally attentive service, including accommodating Crohn's disease and other dietary restrictionsFresh, homemade bread served with meals

What Visitors Say

Visitors frequently mention the massive portion sizes that often lead to leftovers.

The warm herb bread served at the beginning is a common highlight in reviews.

Many reviewers appreciate the quiet atmosphere, even with TVs present.

Don't Miss

Massive Portions

Reliably yield leftovers for another meal, making it great for families.

Wood-Fired Pizzas

Includes favorites like Johnny's Favorite loaded with toppings.

Quiet Atmosphere

Provides a pleasant dining experience even during busy hours.

Unlimited Bread Service

Warm herb bread served with olive oil, a favorite among visitors.

Affordable Pasta Options

Create Your Own Pasta is a popular choice for value.

Know Before You Go

  • Plan to arrive early on weekends to avoid long wait times.
  • Consider calling ahead for takeout during peak tourist times.
  • Be aware that parking can be challenging during busy hours.

What Visitors Say

Featured from 3,745 reviews

Visitors frequently mention the massive portion sizes that often lead to leftovers.

Opening Hours

Monday11 AM to 9 PM
Tuesday11 AM to 9 PM
Wednesday11 AM to 9 PM
Thursday11 AM to 9 PM
Friday11 AM to 10 PM
Saturday11 AM to 10 PM
Sunday11 AM to 9 PM

Best Times to Visit Johnny Carino's

For the best dining experience, consider making reservations for weekend evenings.

🔥Buzzing
Fridays & Saturdays 6PM - 9PM
☀️Relaxed
Weekday lunches 11AM - 2PM

Tags

Popular

Frequently Asked Questions

Does it offer highchairs for toddlers?

Yes.

Is parking available?

Yes, on-site.

Are there TVs?

Yes.

You May Also Like

More great places in Pigeon Forge

View all

Related Guides

Explore More